| |
KIM |
Densifying Admixtures |
Membranes (Positive side) |
Surface-Applied Products |
| Description of System |
Cementitous material added to fresh concrete to grow billions of needle-like hydration crystals within the concrete mass. |
Mineral and chemical materials (pozzolans and silicates) that fill pores in concrete and reduce permeability when added to fresh concrete. |
Liquid and sheet applied bitumens and polymers affixed to the concrete surface. |
Materials applied to concrete surfaces containing mainly water repellents and sealants. |
| Resistance to hydrostatic water pressure |
. Initiates full hydration
. Improves over time
. Continuous self- healing capabilities |
. Reduces initial absorption but will succumb to pressure of water and contaminants in time
. Will not resist penetration at cracks and voids
|
. Protection breached by any pinhole or seam
. Details, joints and workmanship must be in pristine condition
. Once leaking, will require replacement |
. Similar to densifying admixtures
. Resistance deteriorates from day one until failure
. Once leaking, will require repair |
| Protection of reinforcing steel |
. Permanent protection
. Krystol prevents any permeation of water, contaminants and chloride-laden liquids |
. Limited protection as it slows the water ingress but does not stop it
. No protection from cracks |
. Used in conjunction with other materials
. Details, joints and workmanship must be in pristine condition
. No negative side protection |
• Limited protection as it slows the water ingress in uncracked locations |
| Crack resistance |
. Reduces cracking in plastic and curing stage
. Self heals minor cracking with presence of moisture |
. No crack resistance
. May increase cracking in concrete |
. Will crack if concrete cracks
. Limited time barrier at existing crack locations |
. No crack resistance
. Temporarily fills existing cracks |
| Freeze/thaw durability |
. Improves durability by removing expansion and contraction of water within concrete
. Eliminates water penetration at cracks |
. Improves durability of solid, uncracked concrete
. Rapid steel and load strength deterioration at cracked locations |
. Slows deteriorating factors initially
. Durability contingent on zero tolerance of cracks and openings |
. Slows deteriorating factors initially
. No durability properties at crack locations |
| Application |
. Mixed at batch plant or on-site
. No additional applications required |
. Mixed at batch plant or on-site |
. Requires significant labor component
. Correct jointing and seaming critical to performance |
. Requires significant labor component
. Substrate profile critical to performance |
| Surface preparation |
. No surface prep |
. No surface prep |
. Clean surface
. Smooth surface
. Dry surface |
. Clean surface
. Open pore surface
. Water saturated |
| Construction Schedule |
. Save 10-50% time and construction costs |
. Part of two step system
. Requires crack detailing later |
. Must be applied at completion of structural work, prior to back fill |
. Some require 28 day cured concrete
. Similar scheduling as membranes |
| Effective land usage |
. Can build tight with property lines |
. Can build tight with property lines |
. Space required between property line and concrete for membrane installation |
. Space required between property line and concrete for surface application |
| Sub-surface drainage system |
. Not required |
. Requires drainage under heavy hydrostatic pressures |
. Requires drainage under heavy hydrostatic pressures |
. Requires drainage under heavy hydrostatic pressures |
| Additional coatings |
. Does not affect coatings
. Adhesion excellent for coatings and tiles |
. Does not affect coatings
. Cracks require treatment |
. Poor adhesion for coatings and tiles |
. Possible adhesion problems
. Generally require removal prior to coatings or adhesion |
| Maintenance |
. No maintenance required for the life of the concrete |
. Continuous maintenance required at cracked locations |
. Costly replacement generally required |
. Re-application required in hydrostatic conditions |
| Life of protection |
. Lifetime of the concrete |
. 1 to 2 years
. Used in conjunction with other materials |
. Becomes brittle with age resulting in cracks and openings
. Surface damage will eliminate protection |
. Varies based on exposure to water pressure and surface wear
. Surface damage will cause leaks sooner |
| Performance Guarantee |
. 25 years or life of the concrete |
. None |
. Limited 5 and 10 year
. Conditional on installation by trained applicators |
. None |